Critical Point

Prologue 03 · Returned

Play free now

When and where: April 2023 · 6th-floor review room → Credit Committee room, 8th floor → hallway → document scanning room, basement 1

The case

At five in the morning the Credit Committee agenda goes up on the intranet. The fourth item is 2023-0412, the 31-billion-won loan to FlowOn. Your eleven-page dissent is not in the main file; it is filed as “Attachment 7.” The clause you challenged happens to be Article 7 too. The threshold is 180%; the reported figure is 179.6%.

Assistant Manager Oh Jinwoo sets down a paper cup and spells out how things work. Attachments get read only if the chair asks for them. There are eleven items today and one hour of meeting. Has it occurred to you to work out how many minutes that leaves per item? You don’t have a good answer.

Twenty-eight minutes before the meeting opens, Manager Han Seoyun returns your dissent at the team review stage. At 2 p.m., in the committee room on the 8th floor of head office, the chair, Deputy President Jin Sera, calls Item 4. Han Seoyun reads fourteen lines proposing a conditional approval with Article 7 attached. When Jin Sera mentions Attachment 7, Han Seoyun says it was returned at team review. “A returned annexed opinion is not an agenda item. Next.” Item 4 takes four minutes and twelve seconds.

No one raised a voice, and no one looked at you. Eleven items pass in forty-seven minutes. Out in the hallway afterwards, Han Seoyun tells you about a written opinion she wrote twelve years ago. Request a review, keep a copy, or trust your boss when she says she is protecting you: a door is closing, very quietly.

This chapter's rule: Returned and Protected

The quietest door is the one closed with a promise to protect you. The person closing it once stood outside it too.

Who is in the room

The question this case asks

Does a dissent closed in one sentence really disappear? Between a promise of protection and an opinion with your name on it, which do you hold on to?

Play the game

This page covers only a case's first two scenes. The outcomes of your choices and the story's turns are for you to find in the game. All people, companies, institutions and events in the game are fictional.

← Previous case: Prologue 02 · 2023-0412 All case files Next case: Prologue 04 · Window 4 →