Critical Point

Prologue 02 · 2023-0412

Play free now

When and where: April 2023 · KD Bank head office, 6th-floor trainee desk → Corporate Finance Strategy Team review room → FlowOn headquarters and Gimpo logistics site

The case

April 2023. Loan number 2023-0412 lands in front of you. The borrower is FlowOn, a dawn-delivery logistics platform, asking for 31 billion won in working capital. The reported debt-to-equity ratio is 179.6%, just 0.4 percentage points under the bank’s 180% line.

Team Head Yoon Sanghyuk rests his palm on top of your monitor. It is a group strategy project, he says; you will handle the due diligence, and the written opinion is due next Tuesday at 6 p.m. He looks almost as if he is congratulating you. Your first solo file, he calls it, and a company like this comes along once in ten years. The credit committee meets on April 27.

You head out to FlowOn’s headquarters and Gimpo Fulfillment Center 2 for your first due diligence. The founder, Kwon Taeho, gives the tour himself. The company he started with two trucks has grown in eight years to 1,140 employees moving 210,000 boxes a day. Bankers always look at the numbers first, he says, but he wants you to start with Line 3, because those people are the company. His finger doesn’t hesitate as he spreads out the papers showing 179.6%. At six in the evening, 380 night-shift workers come in for the changeover.

Everything you are shown is real. The trouble is in what you are not shown. Revenue has been booked four weeks early, and undone, the real ratio is 184.2%. And Article 7, the clause that lets the bank call the loan the moment debt crosses the line, was written in by your own team. Whether you write your dissent alone, with others, or softened is now up to you.

This chapter's rule: Numbers and Signatures

0.4 percentage points is not a question of math. It is a question of who drew that line.

Who is in the room

The question this case asks

Is 0.4 percentage points a matter of arithmetic, or a matter of who drew the line? Facing a number just under the threshold, whose name goes on your dissent?

Play the game

This page covers only a case's first two scenes. The outcomes of your choices and the story's turns are for you to find in the game. All people, companies, institutions and events in the game are fictional.

← Previous case: Prologue 01 · Trainee Badge All case files Next case: Prologue 03 · Returned →