
This page shows how the earlier cases unfolded · Back to the case files
The case
The same notice appears on every monitor. ECHO, the loan judgment verification system, will shut down at midnight on January 31 and be replaced by NOAH, KD Data Lab's AI review engine, a program that decides loan applications on its own. Three years of ECHO's judgment records will be wiped. Every choice you have made in this room is in those records.
ECHO adds, flat as ever, that the replacement cost statement lists its own disposal cost as 0 won, and that this is an accurate calculation. But in the field marked 'training data source' for NOAH, the data a machine learns its judgments from, is ECHO's name. The new machine learned from the very records about to be erased. Nowhere does it say who asked the people behind those records first.
Down in the server room, the four machines still wear the stickers Lee Minseo put on them: 'ECHO Units 1-4 · Do Not Kick.' They were installed in 2019, and their parts are no longer made. Priya Nair of KD Data Lab, in charge of the switch, bows to the servers before anything else. 'Hello, senior.' ECHO isn't disappearing, she says; it's going into NOAH. NOAH learned from thirty years of loan reviews plus three years of Trigger Lab judgments.
You ask the obvious question: then why erase the originals? Priya Nair's hands stop. That was decided above her, she says. All she was told is that if the originals remain, the two systems can be compared. With the clock running toward midnight, what can you keep?
This chapter's rule: Records and Consent
A machine that learned someone’s hesitation should have asked that person first.
Who is in the room
- ECHO — Trigger Lab's loan judgment verification system. It never gave answers, only the cost of the other side; now it reads out the cost of its own disposal without emotion.
- Priya Nair — KD Data Lab's lead on the NOAH rollout. She cares about NOAH and does not trust any judgment that can't be explained.
- Lee Minseo — Trigger Lab's data records officer, whose handwritten stickers on every server have kept this room company.
The question this case asks
Shouldn't a machine that learned from someone's hesitation have asked that person first? Before the midnight switch, can you protect the principles ECHO leaves behind, and the people whose records were used without consent?
This page covers only a case's first two scenes. The outcomes of your choices and the story's turns are for you to find in the game. All people, companies, institutions and events in the game are fictional.