Critical Point

Case 05 · No One Was Guilty

Play free now

When and where: 2025 · Onsae operations review room → Care dispatch recovery control room

The case

Yesterday, 312 households missed their home care visit. Older people living alone, people who cannot easily get out of bed: no carer came to their door. You leave the operations review room of Onsae, a care platform, and step into the control room that is trying to restore dispatch, the system that decides which carer goes to which home. On the wall map there are 312 red dots.

Reporters want a name. But something does not add up. The field staff followed the manual. The dispatch system ran on approved criteria. Ban Jaewook, an investigator from Internal Audit, has traced the rules all the way to the top, and what he found there was not a person but a budget cap. That cap came straight down from the repayment terms Onsae agreed with its bank. In his notebook, the line for a name is still blank.

ECHO, the review system, lays the decisions of three departments onto a single sheet. The budget team kept to the cap. Operations followed the priority rules. The system applied the approved weights, the values that say how heavily each condition counts. Every piece is clean on its own, yet where they overlap, 312 people fall through the gap. The weighting table’s approval history shows one name in the final reviewer field, and a review time of just six minutes.

There is no obvious villain this time. Everyone followed the rules, and people were still hurt. Writing down one name would end the news cycle, but it would not stop the same failure from happening again. Your job is to separate blame from the things that can actually be fixed. The authority you hold in this case is to set the order of stopping, restoring and assigning responsibility.

This chapter's rule: Rules and Recovery

Check that the rule that stops a repeat does not deepen the harm on the ground.

Who is in the room

The question this case asks

If everyone followed the rules and 312 people were still left behind, whose responsibility is it? Between naming one person and stopping the same failure from happening again, which do you do first?

Play the game

This page covers only a case's first two scenes. The outcomes of your choices and the story's turns are for you to find in the game. All people, companies, institutions and events in the game are fictional.

← Previous case: Case 04 · The Price to Pay All case files Next case: Case 06 · The Person in the Same Room →